RC-Monster Forums

RC-Monster Forums (https://www.rc-monster.com/forum/index.php)
-   Brushless (https://www.rc-monster.com/forum/forumdisplay.php?f=12)
-   -   Nitro sucks!!!!!! (https://www.rc-monster.com/forum/showthread.php?t=18102)

Getter Robo 01.17.2009 09:57 AM

I shot me a MB5 Prospec roller at ebay for a brushless conversion. Even after taking apart and cleaning it I can still find spots to get my hands dirty. Nasty!

BrianG 01.17.2009 10:17 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rivermaxx (Post 252992)
Well so far the fastest proven top speed for a revo is 66mph held by a nitro on the Traxxas forum. ....

There's someone here who has gotten an MT up and over 70mph. Can't remember the name. There just isn't much fun in a truck designed just for speed runs, unless it is specifically designed for it.

Think about it:

1: Nitros rpm range is around 30k. BL is about there and up to 60k depending on the motor.

2: Nitro power band is the typical curve; low power at low rpm and then increases until the peak, which is typically fairly near the upper end of the rpm range. BL torque is instant, which is where it counts for acceleration.

So, there are no power benefits to nitro. BL could be made for high speed, but most of us like to use them for racing or bashing, and a high speed truck doesn't do either of those well

JERRY2KONE 01.17.2009 10:24 AM

Proof is in the pudding.
 
Hey Rivermaxx we are happy that you have come to play here at RCM, and that you are slowly making the change over to BL, but you are right there is no love lost here for nitro and that is not going to change even though some of the guys here run both.

As far as your comment on the BL Revo well things are just begining to heat up in that respect. We all know that the power of BL is much higher than nitro, especially on take off. A DC motor has twice the torque of a nitro setup, and a steady flow of power until the batteries reach their miliamp limits. That end is only getting better and better. As for the ESC's and other electronics burning up. A lot of those events are due to improper setups, Poor choice of equipment matching, and lack of knowledge for the most part. Even the manufacturers are still in the learning curve for BL so we are at their mercy. Still if you do your homework and make the right choices for your setup I would be willing to bet that you could give your old nitro counterparts a run for the money, and probably convince them to try BL due to your showing. It is still a matter of preference just like fans of Ford or Chevy or whatever. Who really cares anyway. Just have fun running what ever you can get your hands on and enjoy the hobby. Lifes too short. Good luck with that guys. Can't we all just get along???

George16 01.17.2009 10:27 AM

Jzemaxx. His XTM went to 80.4mph.

Thread:
http://www.rc-monster.com/forum/showthread.php?t=12163

Video:
http://jp.youtube.com/watch?v=ERY9_TLF86M&feature=user

jhautz 01.17.2009 10:33 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rivermaxx (Post 252992)
Well so far the fastest proven top speed for a revo is 66mph held by a nitro on the Traxxas forum. Hmm Let see wheres that hat with the propeller on it LOL. I can tell you what my full Supermaxx with an eb modded novarossi 528 xrp definatly is no slouch. I expect it to go ~65mph because I have heard a lower powered SM go 72mph. Cmon I still see you guys having problems with burning up ecms and frying $300 brushless motors you cant say electrics dont have their problems also, lets be honest. I plan on doing a conversion on one of my trucks and have been reading alot on this forum for about 2 weeks. Ive see all of the problems you guys are still having I just dont want to put down the cash and have any issues. You must realize nitro is proven and has been around a long time for rc's. If your going to bash it makes me want to ask that person if they drive a 1:1 gasoline or deisel powered vehicle and if so their a hypocrite for not driving a hybrid or electric car. Yes I know electrics are the future and nitros are on their way out. But until then nitros are still on top untill the brushless mills start winning more races.

expect that 66 mph to be beaten by a box stock e-revo brushless edition when they hit the shelf. throw a 6s pack in there and maybe a few extra teeth on the pinion and bye-bye 66mph record.

JERRY2KONE 01.17.2009 10:38 AM

Hopeful
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by George16 (Post 253008)

I know that I have plans on hitting 100mph with my SuperMaxx before the end of the year 2009. Anything is possible. I know the technology is already out there, and you just have to find the right setup to reach your goal. If you want to go fast all you have to do is research and make the right choices in your purchases. There is more to going fast then just slapping a vehicle together and pushing the trigger. The goal for most of us is just to go out and have fun. Sometimes that has been shaming the nitro guys into submission with the right BL setup. Don't be a hater...

George16 01.17.2009 10:42 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by JERRY2KONE (Post 253013)
Don't be a hater...

I'm not a hater. I'm a lover :lol::lol::intello:.

starscream 01.17.2009 10:50 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by JERRY2KONE (Post 253007)
Lifes too short. Good luck with that guys. Can't we all just get along???

You are right about life being too short. I'd rather spend my finite time here not putting up with obnoxious smoke, fumes, and noise. At times I feel I should wear a hasmat suit along with ear plugs while I'm around the nitros as by the end of most race days my eyes burn, my lungs hurt and my ears are ringing. Nitros are just not a healthy way of RC and I for one will be happy when I no longer have to race with them :party:

The truth is that I just don't get along with Nitros, thats why I don't run them.

starscream 01.17.2009 10:53 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by George16 (Post 253014)
I'm not a hater. I'm a lover :lol::lol::intello:.

I'm a lover too. I love it when the price of Nitromethane goes up and up :intello:

Ryu James 01.17.2009 12:17 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jhautz (Post 253011)
expect that 66 mph to be beaten by a box stock e-revo brushless edition when they hit the shelf. throw a 6s pack in there and maybe a few extra teeth on the pinion and bye-bye 66mph record.


i was gonna say...66mph is nothing.. well, its fast but i have seen plenty of brushless setups do that. Kulangflow from here on the forum has a revo that i would be willing to bet does at least 55mph. and that is just his regular setup. thats not trying to be "fast" or anything. all he would have to do to break that 66mph is change his gearing. and yes, the new brushless revo coming out will definitely do. i guarantee within a couple of weeks there will be tons of videos on you tube with guys trying to break 100mph.

nitro is not bad. i was just bitching about it. just pointing out the reasons we all like brushless. 1/8 nitro has given us most of our rides we all like. the truggies, buggies, and MTs. if it werent for brushless i wouldnt be in this hobby most likely. i had electrics as a kid and loved them. then i got a hobby grade nitro 6 years ago and i had too many complaints. 4 months ago when i walked into a hobby store for the hell of it and heard about this somewhat new electric technology called "brushless' and that is was more powerful and faster than nitro i was so excited. needless to say i have been addicted ever since. or as Star likes to put it..."afflicted." i like that. its a total affliction to my wallet. lol.

@ Rivermaxx,
have you converted a 1/8 yet? do you have a setup with a Neu motor and enerland cells? take the opportunity to do this and i am willing to bet you will never go back to your nitro. you may keep them still but your new brushless would outperform your nitros in every single way. not trying to hate, just convert you to the light. we need to baptize you with brushless!!:lol:

BL_RV0 01.17.2009 12:21 PM

Pics?

George16 01.17.2009 12:29 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ryu James (Post 253045)
@ Rivermaxx,
have you converted a 1/8 yet? do you have a setup with a Neu motor and enerland cells? take the opportunity to do this and i am willing to bet you will never go back to your nitro. you may keep them still but your new brushless would outperform your nitros in every single way. not trying to hate, just convert you to the light. we need to baptize you with brushless!!:lol:


I agree with that assessment. My nitros had been on the background ever since I converted my emaxx to brushless :intello:.

redshift 01.17.2009 01:02 PM

lol the Nitro forum here should be a dedicated inteRveNTIOn section, focused on those who need our help the most...

BrianG 01.17.2009 01:51 PM

To be fair, there are a number of benefits of nitro, listed below:

1: You don't mind going mudding, because even if you don't, the combination of dirt and nitro oil will make mud anyway.

2: Realism I guess. Although, I've never known a 1:1 car to sound like a giant mosquito, nor do they smell so bad I want to vomit.

3: Fumes contributes to global warming. With the temps here right now (and the last few days), it would be welcome.

4: Fumes gets you high without resorting to illegal drugs.

5: Gives you exercise. Not only do you have to walk over to flip the vehicle back over, you have to walk to your pit area to restart it.

6: The noise gives the neighbors something to complain about.

7: Most animals won't chase a nitro. Not only are they loud, but the fumes keeps them away. I guess that makes animals are smarter than nitro users.

8: Making you think you are cool because you can work on an "engine".

That's about all I can think of right now, but I'm sure you guys can come up with others...

hootie7159 01.17.2009 02:54 PM

9: Carrying around the starter box, glow plugs, extra fuel, batteries for the receiver, batteries for the starter, and an extra gallons of fuel will get you stronger as well...good for your muscles and cardio...

10: Who want to clean off their car with just an airhose anyways? Its just too easy!!!

11: Taking apart your nitro engine and then putting it back together and NOT having it start is WAY more fun than changing a brushless motor's bearings...

12: Four words...Clutch bells, clutch shoes....yesssss..gotta love those springs!!!!

13: Plug and Play is soooo overrated...I'd rather take out my car, put some fuel in it...Then attempt to start it for the next 20min and figure out why its not starting instead of the electric guys who are already on their 2nd battery...


my 2cents...


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 01:42 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions Inc.