![]() |
Personally, this is what I think about the Neus:
They have pretty low turn counts compared to their KV ratings. For instance, the 2.5 turn Neu 1512 2d has about the same kv as a 6 turn XL motor (and same delta coil configuration). So, this leads me to believe that the Neu has a highly inductive coil setup to compensate for lack of wire resistance. High inductive loads can be VERY difficult to drive due to the phase angles of current and voltage when driven by an AC signal (which is essentially what PWM DC is). It also doesn't help that the Neu coils are wrapped around a core of sorts to concentrate the magentic field for a stronger, more tightly controlled magnetic effect. When you add a core to an inductor, you immediately change its inductance value substantially. I don't think the MM has the software to deal with these types of motors. But the Quark apparently does. Maybe the Quark's programming compensates for a "difficult" motor by adjusting timing, switching frequency, who knows? After all, both ESCs use the same FETs, so it's not a electronic capacity issue. We also know that MM's problem is not because the Neu is a 4 poler, because people have run 4-6 pole motors with apparently no issue. I think MM's problem is strictly in software. We also have to remember that the MM was designed specifically for MM motors. Since they are 2 polers, it only makes sense that most other 2 polers work as well. However, I bet if there was a two pole motor built similar to the Neu with low turn counts (yet typical KV rating) and a cored soil setup, that 2 pole would have similar problems as the Neu. To be clear; I'm not knocking the Neus by any means. I LOVE mine and it works great on the Quark. |
Ok thanks and strangely i think i understand that, you are saying that the inductance coil changes the kv like more winds do, or changing the winding config, right?
|
I don't think inductance by itself changes the kv, but a coil wrapped around a core of some type might since it concentrates the magentic line of flux, thereby directing more magnetic energy to the rotor. The core also changes inductance though.
|
What i meant is, the inductor/coil fools thing to run slower. Like changing the magnetic field so it feels like a higher turn with more windings but less wire so it would still be light
|
Quote:
Yes I work at Tekin, it's our family business. I wouldn't run the R1 Pro with anything bigger than 4s. It wasn't designed for Monster Truck use, like the R1MT will be. Actual current limit is 600a peak per phase and actual voltage limit, we rated it at 12.6v. You saw the video, that was on 16.8v with the BEC disabled. |
Good thing you are online! welcome to RC-monster, can you please shine your light on this; I was wondering if it would be wise to use transil diodes over the three motor phases? since fetts are kind of allergic to over voltage, and the reserves in voltage are limited?
|
How long will it take befor the MT comes out?
The Prez also said he would not mind making a HV version of the R1MT. What's your comments on what he said? |
when does it come out?
|
TY, thanks for the straight forward info. It sounds like the current handling isn't the problem (for 1/8 scale application), but rather the low voltage handling.
I'd be willing to try an R1 Pro in an MT on 4S. What is your repair policy (cost) going to be to repair an R1 Pro if/when I blow it up? Are you guys going to have a flat rate repair fee, or will it depend on what smoked? I really hate to sound like I'm going to jump right in a start off abusing the equipment, but it's what I'll have to do, since I don't own any 1/10 scale vehicles. BTW, I just wanted to mention that the guy that owns my LHS speaks very highly of your products. Since he's around all sorts of makes and models of equipment, it is real praise when he says that one line of products is better than the rest. |
Quote:
You are not fooling anything, it is what it is, because that's what it is. Brian: About the Neu's, they are 4 pole right, so double the amount of poles, you need to roughly cut your number of turns in half, don't you? |
Quote:
LOL, appearently you haven't been around our forums too much. We do alot of things we aren't supposed to. We promise to do alot of "post-beta" testing for you. :o |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
I emailed Tekin the other day about the R1MT, and this was their reply:
Quote:
|
that is good news. now if we just knew when it is coming out.
|
Cool!!!! Now for just a date on the big one.
|
yeah bring on the 6s charge
|
Yupppppeeeeeey!!!!
The Prez did take care of us. Thanks, boss! |
YES!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !
this ROCKs!!!!! now i just need a truggy.......lol |
Why not just put it in your e-revo?
|
Bah!
|
Quote:
|
LOL yep!
and the revo still doesnt have a place in my heart to sink the money lol |
hahaha good point.
|
yup yup
but anyways back on topic, u guys think this will stay cool? or the like the quark? |
Quote:
|
Serum is right. But I think that it should be fine. I can get the my quark now to run without thermal, but I think that any esc if pushed will thermal anyway, electronics, go figure!
|
yeah true true, i debut i will even run 6 cell, but u never know, lol idk i will be racing my trugg, so i think 4 or 5 cell
|
picture of the r1pro is on www.teamtekin.com
|
I thought the r1pro was to be for more cells? It's like the MM now? Rated 3s Lipo
|
it does 4s and 5s with the bec disabled tough.
|
Quite small in comparison to the Mamba Max!
The MT version might just be as big as the Mamba Max then. |
any news yet?
|
I emailed them about a week ago, and they said that the only info they can give is on the website. But... there is nothing on the website, so...
|
well what i can say is, the r1 and the tekin redline motors were a blow for racing, 7 guys went from the whole tekin setup (and there sponcered by tekin!!) went to a lrp worlds tc spec ec and the lrp motor
no one liked the esc =( i hope the r1mt is a good basher esc |
Wow, I'm really surprised. I expected the R1 systems to be a big hit. Maybe they'll work better for the bashers or offroad racers.
|
Quote:
lap times went from 13.6, down to 13 flat in some places, just u can tell th elrp was SOOOOO much smoother then the tekin heat wasnt a issue, just want the best race (onroad anyways) system i still have big hope in the r1mt tho |
and btw, thats with just the guy dropping in the lrp on race day, i watched him as i wanted to see the brand new lrp speedo... just dropped it in, wired it up neately, and dropped in a batt, and afer that the other 6 switched lol.. made some money from that
|
Ah, that's on-road...not the same animal...
|
| All times are GMT -4. The time now is 06:26 PM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions Inc.