RC-Monster Forums

RC-Monster Forums (https://www.rc-monster.com/forum/index.php)
-   General Discussion (https://www.rc-monster.com/forum/forumdisplay.php?f=20)
-   -   Traxxas Summit New Truck (https://www.rc-monster.com/forum/showthread.php?t=15891)

TexasSP 10.16.2008 10:35 AM

Traxxas Summit New Truck
 
http://www.traxxas.com/products/promo/5610_promo.htm

Looks interesting enough.

I like the remote locking differentials and changeable 75:1 and 25:1 final drive ratios.

The 775 motor looks interesting but I think BL would be better for sure. I also dig the body and LED's.

snellemin 10.16.2008 10:38 AM

I like the remote locking diffs.

skellyo 10.16.2008 10:51 AM

Not impressed. It's an E-Revo with some lipstick on it to make you think it's capable of crawling.

FullMetalGrave 10.16.2008 11:04 AM

I kinda like it. Wonder if the tranny and remote locking diffs can hang with a 1515 Neu? :lol:

TexasSP 10.16.2008 11:13 AM

I may have to find out! :mdr:

jnev 10.16.2008 11:17 AM

Although this truck has very cool features, I wish Traxxas would build a whole new truck around these features (locking diffs, lights, exo cage, transmission, etc.). They are starting to turn into Losi with just redesigning an already built truck... Still have to say though that the features Traxxas thought of are VERY cool. :yes:

Arct1k 10.16.2008 11:21 AM

Agree - Locking diffs are a nice touch but a revo is not really a crawler platform - I'm amazed that this is their crawler solution - I though more like losi or duratrax.

RUSTY XL-5 10.16.2008 11:25 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jnev (Post 223030)
Although this truck has very cool features, I wish Traxxas would build a whole new truck around these features (locking diffs, lights, exo cage, transmission, etc.). They are starting to turn into Losi with just redesigning an already built truck... Still have to say though that the features Traxxas thought of are VERY cool. :yes:

Although its a cool truck, I totally agree with you. I will they would come out with a totally different vehicle instead or always "re-designing". :whip:

TexasSP 10.16.2008 11:36 AM

I don't get the whole redesigning bashing. Every stinking RC company out there does this. How many versions of the savage has their been, not to mention touring cars, and others. It's not just losi and TRX, it's everyone.

JThiessen 10.16.2008 11:40 AM

I look at it as more cool parts for my Revo...:intello:

lincpimp 10.16.2008 11:43 AM

That is cool, I may have to get one. I would like to see two of the 775 motors though.

Arct1k 10.16.2008 11:58 AM

So you can now make a platinum brushelss e-Slayer with locking diff's and led's

kulangflow 10.16.2008 12:04 PM

I really like the idea of the Summit. When I was first running an E-maxx 5 years ago, I was dreaming it had the remote locking diffs and waterproofnessicitytionability.

RUSTY XL-5 10.16.2008 12:43 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TexasSP (Post 223037)
I don't get the whole redesigning bashing. Every stinking RC company out there does this. How many versions of the savage has their been, not to mention touring cars, and others. It's not just losi and TRX, it's everyone.

I understand why a company comes out with a "better" version of the same truck over the years, but what I get tired of is a company using the same parts/platform for vehicle after vehicle. (the Summit is basically a rock crawler converted E-Revo, the Slayer is basically a "stubby" Revo, the Slash is basically a Rustler with a different chassis/body). Now, don't get me started on Losi. :lol:


Don't get me wrong, I love all of Traxxas' vehicles, I just wish they put more creativity into them. ;)

BrianG 10.16.2008 01:00 PM

From a customer standpoint, I don't mind "borrowing" individual components that work well from different vehicles, but don't slap a new body on something, change one or two items, and call it different. It feels like companies are trying to be deceptive and are just out to make a quick and dirty dollar. It would be nice to see something different once in a while, just to mix things up.

On the other hand, from a company standpoint; if something works well, why not keep using it? No need to re-invent the wheel after all. Not to mention R&D and manufacturing costs are lower since many parts are recycled.

So, I can see both points.

TexasSP 10.16.2008 01:20 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by RUSTY XL-5 (Post 223066)
Don't get me wrong, I love all of Traxxas' vehicles, I just wish they put more creativity into them. ;)

But how do you look at the summit and think "meh, there's no creativity there"? I think most of the features are spot on and very creative. No one has done anything quite like it before.

Keep in mind that from my standpoint this is all friendly discussion. :intello:

skellyo 10.16.2008 01:25 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by BrianG (Post 223070)
On the other hand, from a company standpoint; if something works well, why not keep using it? No need to re-invent the wheel after all. Not to mention R&D and manufacturing costs are lower since many parts are recycled.

While the E-Revo may work well as a basher, it's not a crawler, nor trail truck. Adding in a low gear and locking diffs and trying to pass it off as such is just ridiculous. In this particular case, Traxxas really should have designed at least a mostly new vehicle to fit the intended purpose.

From the ad they had on the back of the special edition RCCA crawling mag, one would have expected at least some semblance of a crawler instead of this thing.

Andrew32 10.16.2008 01:26 PM

i have mixed feelings on this one

Def wont see this thing going competitive for sure!:no:
but i really REALLY REALLY like the hi/lo rang transmission and locking differentials. I assume the 3 positions is LSD, rear lock, rear and front lock.

but i agree, i was really looking forward to traxxas coming out with a 4 link solid axle 1/8 scale monster....i guess the summit is more of a trail truck than a crawler

**runs to traxxas forum to see waht people think.....DOUGHHHHHHHHHHHHH......runs back screaming.**

i guess well have to wait and see what it can do...

brushlessboy16 10.16.2008 01:43 PM

wow, great concept but traxxas resuses old designs wayyyy too much... i think the crawler guys will really like the the locking diffs, i do :yes:

wonder how much power they can take:wink:

Tempted 10.16.2008 01:44 PM

It is a terrible truck with neat features. I would like the selectable lockers on my truck. But all this is a jacked up Revo with the two speed conversion and lower gears. If they wanted a crawler, take the Maxx truck, bolt some solid axles under it with those cool lockers and lift the heck out of it. I would prefer they just start from scratch but that will never happen. When is their last completely new truck? The Slayer is just a messy Revo, the Slash is just a tuned up Rusty, The E-Revo is cool, but its based on an old truck. Nothing new from Traxxas.

crazyjr 10.16.2008 01:47 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jnev (Post 223030)
Although this truck has very cool features, I wish Traxxas would build a whole new truck around these features (locking diffs, lights, exo cage, transmission, etc.). They are starting to turn into Losi with just redesigning an already built truck... Still have to say though that the features Traxxas thought of are VERY cool. :yes:

What do you mean "traxxas turning into Losi"? Traxxas has rehashed most of their current line more than Losi has, and for longer.

My opinion, I like the summit. I really don't do much for trail running and i don't do crawling, but i can appricate the engineering to bring it to market.

JThiessen 10.16.2008 02:08 PM

Anyone else notice the CV joints on the drive shafts! Definitley looking forward to those.

RUSTY XL-5 10.16.2008 02:38 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TexasSP (Post 223072)
But how do you look at the summit and think "meh, there's no creativity there"? I think most of the features are spot on and very creative. No one has done anything quite like it before.

Keep in mind that from my standpoint this is all friendly discussion. :intello:


I guess I wasn't specific enough. My bad. :oops:


When I meant more creativity, I meant not borrow and E-Revo chassis, Revo front and rear suspension set up, slap them all together, add a sprinkle of rock crawler friendly features. IMO the Summit is just a rock crawling capable E-Revo. I dont see it as a real crawler. I see a real crawler as a vehicle with tubular (or similar) chassis set-up and solid axle suspension (not independent).



I do LOVE the locking diffs though, VERY cool!

kulangflow 10.16.2008 03:12 PM

Traxxas says the Summit probably won't be released until February, but the Brushless E-Revo should be out in December.

skellyo 10.16.2008 03:19 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by kulangflow (Post 223102)
Traxxas says the Summit probably won't be released until February

Traxxas isn't usually like that. They usually have the product available within 2 months of the release. Wonder why this one is different?

JThiessen 10.16.2008 03:50 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by RUSTY XL-5 (Post 223095)
I guess I wasn't specific enough. My bad. :oops:


When I meant more creativity, I meant not borrow and E-Revo chassis, Revo front and rear suspension set up, slap them all together, add a sprinkle of rock crawler friendly features. IMO the Summit is just a rock crawling capable E-Revo. I dont see it as a real crawler. I see a real crawler as a vehicle with tubular (or similar) chassis set-up and solid axle suspension (not independent).



I do LOVE the locking diffs though, VERY cool!

I guess depending on how you read between the lines, to me they aren't marketing it as a full tilt crawler. They seem to be more pushing the line of dual purpose. Not a bad marketing strategy if you ask me. On the other hand, the revo suspension is arguably the best out there. It would be to their advantage to sell the crap out of it for the time that they hold exclusive rights to that patent.

Arct1k 10.16.2008 03:53 PM

I don't think they have a patent on the shock layout the DM1 uses the same setup...

kraegar 10.16.2008 04:08 PM

This is a tough one for me. I've been holding off on getting a crawler so I could see what Traxxas was coming out with.

I've already got an e-revo, and while some of the features such as the remote locking diff are cool, I can't see getting this to go along with my e-revo. Not enough difference to justify it. If I was just now getting into the market for an e-revo or a crawler, this would be great.

So I think I'm going to look into either an axial or the losi mrc. (probably an axial artr)

Though having the spare parts for an e-revo & the experience with one would make working on the summit easier, I think the learning about a whole new truck would be more fun.

- Tony

e-rev project 10.16.2008 04:32 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by kraegar (Post 223117)
This is a tough one for me. I've been holding off on getting a crawler so I could see what Traxxas was coming out with.

I've already got an e-revo, and while some of the features such as the remote locking diff are cool, I can't see getting this to go along with my e-revo. Not enough difference to justify it. If I was just now getting into the market for an e-revo or a crawler, this would be great.

So I think I'm going to look into either an axial or the losi mrc. (probably an axial artr)

Though having the spare parts for an e-revo & the experience with one would make working on the summit easier, I think the learning about a whole new truck would be more fun.

- Tony

wow that what my Exact train of thought, i just finished my revo conversion, and was waiting to see what truck went with that magazine ad awhile back. A crawler is my next project too, unless something happens with tomorrows release I'm going Axial artr.

remote locking diff is sweet though, hope it can take our kind of power:yes:

shizzon 10.16.2008 04:45 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by RUSTY XL-5 (Post 223066)
I understand why a company comes out with a "better" version of the same truck over the years, but what I get tired of is a company using the same parts/platform for vehicle after vehicle. (the Summit is basically a rock crawler converted E-Revo, the Slayer is basically a "stubby" Revo, the Slash is basically a Rustler with a different chassis/body). Now, don't get me started on Losi. :lol:


Don't get me wrong, I love all of Traxxas' vehicles, I just wish they put more creativity into them. ;)

From a manufacturing point of view to developing a completely new platform is far more costly/time consuming then simply changing/tweaking an existing model. The change in tooling to occompany a completely new model (ie. developing new molds for the plastic parts and the many other processes in manufacturing that would have to be changed) would be very expensive, while making just a vew more molds to change an existling platform would be a much quicker and cost effective alternative. These two benefits will be passed on to the consumer in the time it takes to be released and the initial cost of the product.

Arct1k 10.16.2008 04:48 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by shizzon (Post 223121)
From a manufacturing point of view to developing a completely new platform is far more costly/time consuming then simply changing/tweaking an existing model. The change in tooling to occompany a completely new model (ie. developing new molds for the plastic parts and the many other processes in manufacturing that would have to be changed) would be very expensive, while making just a vew more molds to change an existling platform would be a much quicker and cost effective alternative. These two benefits will be passed on to the consumer in the time it takes to be released and the initial cost of the product.

We understand it is just a touch boring :)

shizzon 10.16.2008 04:52 PM

donyt get me wrong, i like change as much as the next guy. Just pointing out that there are reason's why this happens. I too wish it would have been a new rockcrawler platform, as it probably would have been my next buy, The summet, however cool with its new feartures, is just a little to similar to my E-revo for me to go and get one.

suicideneil 10.16.2008 04:53 PM

I think it sucks.

*new shell with LEDs = lame
*locking diffs = how long do you reckon those will last before they strip or bust?
*beadlock wheels and funky tyres = nice, but nothing amazing

I agree with those that have said its just a re-hashed Erevo pretending to be a trail truck/ crawler; crawlers are solid axle with a minimal chassis, trail trucks are most often scale vehicles and not big lumpy MTs.

Nice try traxxas, but you fail.

jnev 10.16.2008 05:50 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by crazyjr (Post 223084)
What do you mean "traxxas turning into Losi"? Traxxas has rehashed most of their current line more than Losi has, and for longer.

My opinion, I like the summit. I really don't do much for trail running and i don't do crawling, but i can appricate the engineering to bring it to market.

What I mean is that Losi has used the same basic platform for many vehicles. For example, the LST2, Aftershock, and Raminator are all VERY similar and have the same basic design/layout. Same with their 1/18 models, MLST, Mini Raminator, etc. And now Traxxas uses the same platform to make another similar vehicle. Traxxas did this much better than Losi did however in my opinion, as they actually made some pretty big changes... just not as many as I'd like to see. :wink:

jefierro 10.16.2008 05:56 PM

hmm, looks very familiar.:surprised:

http://jefierro.com/E-MAXX/MonsterTo...erLives-03.jpg

I'll say is fun to semi crawl with this one but a spool and low gears doesn't make a rock crawler. But still very capable in uneven terrain.
I also was expecting a solid axle crawler but for those like me that didn't like the looks of the solid axles is a good idea and is very tempting:whistle:.

hoovhartid 10.16.2008 09:00 PM

yeah. I like having more options for my e-revo. When I get bored with it the way it is, I can go for the short arm slash set-up, or a high rise summit. I like the options that will keep me from getting bored. Its a great all-in-one platform, but I think it would be cooler if they called it that. The e-revo; The e-revo short course; The e-revo crawler Ed.

I dont know crap about poop when it comes to crawlers, but all the (good) ones I have seen keep their weight really low. Have independant motors for the front and back ends. Have the ability to steer the front and rear independantly.....I donno, I gree with most. The summit isnt really a good lookin crawler to me.

E-Revonut 10.16.2008 09:43 PM

Personally I think the locking diffs are cool, the locking rings are steel so they should hold up for awhile. The good thing about traxxas releasing new trucks based off the same chassis is just as hoovartid said, when you get bored with what you have you can change out a few parts and have a whole new truck. Also it's good for the consumer as many of the parts are already available, so when you break it the day you get it you don't hanve to wait for parts!

DRIFT_BUGGY 10.16.2008 09:59 PM

Not bad

hoovhartid 10.16.2008 10:09 PM

compair pics?
http://i87.photobucket.com/albums/k1...am/compair.jpg


after seeing some of the replies.....I think its important that you know....I just copied and pasted those pics together.

I used the front skid plate as a point of size reference, but I can guarantee its NOT perfect. It was done in MS paint program.

Those trucks may not be that different in size.

skellyo 10.16.2008 10:11 PM

Ginormous thing, ain't it!


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 11:28 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions Inc.