Quote:
Originally Posted by 1maxdude
I gotta ask, why so much hate on maxamps? I have one of their packs and it seems to be a terrific performing pack. Everyone always seems to dog on them, unless I have an exceptionally good pack from them. I don't have any graphs or anything like that but in a 5.15 lb rustler with a mamba max 6900 geared extremely high (28/83) it provides every bit of torque it needs to flip the car backwards at any speed, be it take off, mid, or top end with a pull of the trigger. Or maybe my system doesn't draw as many amps as I thought, I don't know. Its a 20c 2s2p 6000hv pack, the only other pack I can compare it to is a 10c 8000 true rc pack, but that isn't a fair comparison. I've had it since February and its as good as ever, I did do a full charge on it the other day and it took 6655 mah. Not to sound like a maxamps thumper, but I've no regrets buying the battery and it satisfies my needs. Are there that many failures out there?
|
I have sent back 90% of the maxamps pack that I bought. That is 9 out of 10. I would have sent the other back, but missed the 30 day window. I had at least one cell puff in each pack, and actually received a pack that had a puffed cell in it. Maxamps packs are fine in a 10th 2wd vehicle. 2wd just can't pull the load, or sustain it like 4wd can. Your 6k pack is 20c rated. I would love to see it produce 120amps... Therein lies the problem, false advertising...
Quote:
Originally Posted by hoober
From what I've read , the problem seems to be with the truth in advertising or marketing. I like all my Maxamps packs. I got a good deal on them , and the ratings are about half of what they are sold as.
If one uses a 20C pack at 10C or less (like 90% of users will) then niether maxamps or user will detect that anything is wrong. I don't expect to get anything close to the rating out of my maxamps packs , so I simply compare said pack to competitors packs at whatever ratings/cost they actually are and make my choice to buy.
The trouble starts showing up when a user thinks it is ok to pull the amount of current that the pack is said to withstand. The pack will overheat, puff up and not last a few cycles , even become a danger to have around.
|
Best to compare weight and size. That seems to be the best bet in comparing lipo ability. I was suprised when I got my first neu lipo. 3s 5000mah 25c battery was almost twice as big as a maxamps 5k 3s. After running it I can safely say that the maxamps was no where near the quality of the neu, and damn close in price. Maxamps has to pay for all of that advertising somehow... And the NitroPuffers forum...
Quote:
Originally Posted by Just go Play
LOL why is it that anything less then being in love with MA is considered hate?
But since you asked... I personally feel the practice of over rating a product that is widely considered to have a high degree of inherent danger even when used as designed to be highly irresponsible of such a large US company that sells their products to a target market group consisting largely of children.
Theres any number of other reasons but w/e
|
The only reason that people say that there is maxamps hating here is becasue they just do not understand the difference. Going from nimh to a maxamps lipo is a huge step, and I think that many wonder how much better can a different lipo be. I have personally tested and owned at least a dozen different brand lipos, and know the difference. Most people do not have 5k to drop on battery testing. I have found that repeatedly that enerland cells perform, and last. I even went as far to buy the oldest 5s 3700 polyrc pack that I could find. It was maintained correctly by the previos owner, but had over 100 cycles on it. I have had it for about 8 months now, and it is still good, capcity and output are right on spec. I just cannot say the same for maxamps.