RC-Monster Forums - View Single Post

JoFreak · 10.17.2010, 01:49 PM

Not really interested in the "lipo-wars" here, but one question remains to all the people who demand to see some graphs:
What does a graph really tell you?
In case of doubt only that someone was quite capable of using power point, photo shop or MS paint and has a good imagination.
In my opinion graphs are meritless if provided by the manufacturer of the product.
Any manufacturer of any of their products that is.
I think a neutral, unbiased tester is the only one to provide a usefull graph.

But then, how do you test a product if it fullfills it's specs, if no sufficient specs are provided?
150C is fine, but for how long? One nano second? 10 seconds burst? Constant discharge? "True" just isn't a concept of time known to me.
Since there are no limiting factors given, to the amount of time the 150C are possible, one would have to assume it is constant discharge.
So maxamps-guys, if you really have any interest in "clearing your name" with the submonsters here, provide some specs so someone can actually test your products.
If not, the fronts will remain as they are.

	(#2)
JoFreak RC-Monster Carbon Fiber Offline Posts: 447 Join Date: Feb 2009 Location: Munich	10.17.2010, 01:49 PM Not really interested in the "lipo-wars" here, but one question remains to all the people who demand to see some graphs: What does a graph really tell you? In case of doubt only that someone was quite capable of using power point, photo shop or MS paint and has a good imagination. In my opinion graphs are meritless if provided by the manufacturer of the product. Any manufacturer of any of their products that is. I think a neutral, unbiased tester is the only one to provide a usefull graph. But then, how do you test a product if it fullfills it's specs, if no sufficient specs are provided? 150C is fine, but for how long? One nano second? 10 seconds burst? Constant discharge? "True" just isn't a concept of time known to me. Since there are no limiting factors given, to the amount of time the 150C are possible, one would have to assume it is constant discharge. So maxamps-guys, if you really have any interest in "clearing your name" with the submonsters here, provide some specs so someone can actually test your products. If not, the fronts will remain as they are.