What heat sink to use on Neu? - RC-Monster Forums

**What heat sink to use on Neu? -** 03.23.2009, 08:31 AM

Hey guys I have a Neu 1515/2.5d with a smooth can and will be using it in a truggy for racing. I would like to put a heat sink on it to try and keep things as cool as possible. What would you recommend? Does Mike make one for this?

03.23.2009, 01:27 PM

anybody?

BrianG · 03.23.2009, 01:32 PM

The only thing I've seen are those heatsink/mounts on ImpaktRC. IIRC, there was somewhere else that had heatsinks for Neus but I can't remember exactly where it was.

03.23.2009, 02:29 PM

Thanks Brian, if you come across the other heatsinks let me know please

suicideneil · 03.23.2009, 10:20 PM

That sounds a bit rude...

Anyway- where's my cookie?

http://www.airpowernet.com/twe/produ...roducts_id=535

They seem to have changed the design a little bit since the last time I looked, but it will fit any 15** motor, might just have to trim the length accordingly.

03.23.2009, 10:28 PM

Cool thanks Neil I likes!

Finnster · 03.23.2009, 10:31 PM

I vote none.
Shouldn't need one, mostly dead weight, and may be insulating if its not machined really tight. Trapped air pockets will hold warm air like a coat.

suicideneil · 03.23.2009, 10:33 PM

I would generally agree, but I guess it depends how extreme the setup is- thermal grease should solve any heat transfer issues though I would have thought.

Finnster · 03.24.2009, 09:52 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by suicideneil

I would generally agree, but I guess it depends how extreme the setup is- thermal grease should solve any heat transfer issues though I would have thought.

Thermal grease is really only very effective if its applied very very thinly and used to smooth out any minor defects. It really can't be used to fill in large gaps. By large I mean 0.1mm. I mean I guess its better than air being there, but it won't make a crappy HS work great if its poorly machined.

IDK if you've ever played around with building computers and attaching HS's onto CPUs. Things are easier today, but the HS for CPUs use a huge amount of spring force, like 30lbs+ to attach a HS onto the little die. Some extreme overclockers or terribly anal people would go further than even the huge aftermarket HSs and "lap" or sand down to a mirror-like finish w/ 1000 grit paper, then use Artic silver to fill in imperfections.
This is a bit of an extreme example as you are trying to dissipate 10's of watts out of a 1 sq cm die, but you could also easily see the results of your HS attachment skills. If you slathered AS all over the die, temperatures would be quite a bit higher. The thinnest scraping produced the best results.

Motor HS don't have to be nearly so efficient as that, and they have a much greater area to dissapate heat, but they do not attach to the surface w/ any amt of spring force, nor are the HS or motor surfaced generally well prepped for HS's and thermal transfer by contact. The machining is fairly rough. If you get some poorly machined cheap chinese HS, I wouldn't count on it doing a whole hell of a lot, and may actually be counter productive (trap air pockets.)

A 2.5D on 5S will be solid and lots of power for the track. More than anything its going to come down to driving skill and proper gearing to being with. With too much power its easy to drive out of control and just bounce off the walls as you watch the slow and steady guy just lap you. If you are getting anywhere near 160 or so, I would look at gearing and setup before fooling with HSs or fans or anything.

03.23.2009, 10:41 PM

Not really that extreme, CEN truggy on 5s with mmm, 1515/2.5d geared 46/15. I don't know that I need the extra cooling I just wanted to have all the bases covered before my first race with it coming up and unfortunately due to the weather around here I doubt that I will be able to test it on anything resembling a track. If you guys think its a waste then I wont even worry about it. What do you think?

Finnster · 03.24.2009, 10:04 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by FastXR

Not really that extreme, CEN truggy on 5s with mmm, 1515/2.5d geared 46/15. I don't know that I need the extra cooling I just wanted to have all the bases covered before my first race with it coming up and unfortunately due to the weather around here I doubt that I will be able to test it on anything resembling a track. If you guys think its a waste then I wont even worry about it. What do you think?

Don't those have those 2.89 ratio diffs? If so you are @ ~9:1 FDR which seems qutie a bit overgeared to me. Personally my trug runs ~14:1 and seems just about perfect temp wise and power wise.
I'm not a Cen expert, so maybe this is off, but if anything that much overgear will be sluggish and hard on the ESC. Motor temps will be low tho most likely. It takes a bit of testing to get it just right. g/l

E-Revonut · 03.23.2009, 10:45 PM

On 5s you should be able to easily gear it to destroy the nitros and still stay cool.

03.23.2009, 10:54 PM

Unfortunately its going to be a 1/8 electric race a run what you brung sorta thing, buggies, truggies and MT's so I won't have to worry about nitros I will be on equal playing ground with most others. I assume most others will be running Castle MMM combos a few of the Novaks and maybe in one or two of the new Tekins it guys can get their hands on them.

E-Revonut · 03.23.2009, 11:07 PM

Most will still gear for about 40 so you should still be ok. On such an efficient motor a heatsink isn't so crucial. Try running without one first, if it gets to hot for your liking then get it.

sleebus.jones · 03.24.2009, 07:58 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by E-Revonut

On such an efficient motor a heatsink isn't so crucial. Try running without one first, if it gets to hot for your liking then get it.

Exactly what I've found out. Heck, I'm running an Aftershock, geared for about 47 MPH on 6S with the Castle 2200Kv and it doesn't want to get hot. I really doubt you'll have any problem with your setup.