Turnigy LiFEPO4 packs

[JThiessen]

Well, unfortunately, it turned into a "He Said - She Said" debate instead of a data comparison between the two types of packs. Both "sides" were somewhat guilty of turning it into that.

If you had several MA Lipos that failed, it really has no bearing on the quality or validity of these particular packs. He did make a good point on pricing - if you don't like it, don't buy it. Their pricing is compatible with A123's pricing, and I have yet to see many forums filled with A123 bashing due to the pricing.

I for one have no doubt that the Asian built packs are factory rejects. Does that mean that they wont perform as well, maybe not - maybe so. Until there is long term testing, no one will know. Even if you were to have both packs brand new, they may perform as well right off the bat, but a factory "second" could start to show its deficiency down the road as it may "age" faster....

I am not a MA fan, and choose to not pay for what I percieve to be a product that is not as good as equivelently priced packs. But, I also wont tell someone that they wasted their money on them.