RC-Monster Forums

RC-Monster Forums (https://www.rc-monster.com/forum/index.php)
-   Brushless (https://www.rc-monster.com/forum/forumdisplay.php?f=12)
-   -   Hobbywing 4465sl 44mm motor (https://www.rc-monster.com/forum/showthread.php?t=22514)

13btoyrota 07.26.2009 12:05 AM

Hobbywing 4465sl 44mm motor
 
Anyone had or tryed one of these bigger hobbywing 2000kv 44mm motors as they are supose to have more tourqe and run cooler like the cc mmm motors as opposed to the 36mm 2045kv feiago motor i have i think has just died after 3 months.

jsr 07.26.2009 01:51 AM

Haven't tried one, but since it's quite a bit larger, it should generate a lot more torque and thus will have less trouble pushing around whatever it is you're pushing. The price for one starts to inch pretty close to a Medusa or CC/Neu, so personally I'd pick up the CC/Neu or Medusa, but if those are still too much, the HW 2000kV 44mm should be a pretty good monster.

BL_RV0 07.26.2009 10:38 AM

It probably is similar in performance to a KB45 L can, except with a 5mm shaft and 25mm hole spacing.

scarletboa 07.26.2009 02:58 PM

i would get a KB45 motor before i'd get the hobbywing motor. the 30mm bolt pattern is the only real downside. grinding the shaft down to 5mm is very easy with a dremel. i had a custom motor mount made for my savage to use KB motors. i only managed to get a 10 min test run on 3s with my 1400kv L sized KB motor until my esc died. the motor temped at 115F after going full throttle (which was about 15mph) for most of the run.

jsr 07.26.2009 08:28 PM

I actually like the HW motors. The end-bells are removeable and held in with screws that are more secure than the pressed-in end-bells of the Feigao/KD/KB motors. If you keep rpms below 40k, you should be fine.

13btoyrota 07.27.2009 03:31 AM

Sorry new to this and not sure what the KB motors are ? [full name].
I am only going to be running 14.8v on it so it will only be doing 29 to 30,000rpm's. Its for a caster converted zx-1 nitro buggy with a 13/46 pinion and spure.

florianz 07.27.2009 04:51 AM

those are the kb45xl or l motors of hobbyking.

littlegiant 07.27.2009 06:06 AM

Hi, please avoid the KB motors. They are very inefficient. They heat up alot even with powerful fans. i run a KB45L 2300kv motor in my 4.7Kg truck geared to 35 - 40mph on 4S lipo and the motor will heat up to 60C within 5 min. Powerful but inefficient. And heat will demagnetise the motor rendering it useless. Go for better motors.

florianz 07.27.2009 06:34 AM

thats right, they get hot easyly. I think the quality is slightly better then the pink kd motors, as the rotor is balanced.
if you need such a big motor and you're on a budget, go for the feigao 580l. it measueres about 44x74 mm, has an 5mm axle. it's not a lehner, but at least better then a kb45. some people are quite happy with the kb45, I think that their quality really varies from average to very poor.

the feigao has some cooling-holes, just put a nylon mesh over it to keep the motor free from stones, dirt.

nitrostarter 07.27.2009 11:11 AM

If you're running a buggy, pick up a CC/Neu motor or a Medusa 36-60-2000 or 36-70-2000.

13btoyrota 07.28.2009 06:22 AM

Im running a converted caster zx1 buggy but i dont want it to go super fast i just want a good strong motor with plenty of tourqe and one i can get realy good run times out of without the motor getting hot.
My freind has a MMM 2200kv combo and in his ex1 caster and its too much for what i want but i have now got a MMM v3 esc but just need a new motor now so somthing around the 1700 to 2000kv range im thinking.

nitrostarter 07.28.2009 10:19 AM

Get the MMM 2650 and run 3s or 4s and gear for 40mph. This will be plenty and MORE efficient than the Hobbywing stuff...

13btoyrota 07.28.2009 10:45 AM

Wouldn't the 2650 make it even faster on 4s than the 2200. Im running a 13 tooth pinion and a 46 spure but do have an 11 tooth pinion also to gear it down to make it slower.

nitrostarter 07.28.2009 10:51 AM

You have to play with the gearing.

junkman 07.28.2009 12:22 PM

I have 2 hw combos, 80a 36/74, in an e-revo, and a 80a 36/60 in an sc8ight. I run them both on 5s and have had no problems to speak of. I too have wanted to try the 44mm motor, but honestly what I have has been plenty for what I do with it. The motors are def better than the kd's, sad when they aren't even worth the $30. I had a mmm/2200 combo in the sc8ight, pulled to put it in an lst, yes the mmm combo had more power, but honestly not night and day difference I was expecting.

florianz 07.28.2009 01:15 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by junkman (Post 308113)
I have 2 hw combos, 80a 36/74, in an e-revo, and a 80a 36/60 in an sc8ight. I run them both on 5s and have had no problems to speak of. I too have wanted to try the 44mm motor, but honestly what I have has been plenty for what I do with it. The motors are def better than the kd's, sad when they aren't even worth the $30. I had a mmm/2200 combo in the sc8ight, pulled to put it in an lst, yes the mmm combo had more power, but honestly not night and day difference I was expecting.

You are running the 80a on 5s? I am very curious about that, as I have been thinking about an 80a to run my losi 1700kv on 5s. what do you think, would that be working in the long run? It's for a heavy buggy w/ truggy wheels. the peak amps shouldn't be too high with that motor.
thanks
flo

junkman 07.28.2009 01:27 PM

yup, 5s on both of them. Kinda crossed my fingers, closed my eyes and pulled the trigger. I dropped a couple pinion teeth on both of them, from 4s. Even the lipo cut works, but you do have to manually set it to 5s, the auto doesn't catch 5s. The revo probably has about 15 cycles on it, the sc8ight maybe 5 or 6. The revo will hit a 8mph or so rolling backflip every time. A racing time situation where you are one it for a constant 15 min or so I don't think it would hold up, but for bashing around no problems so far. The motor gets about 150 or so, but the esc doesn't break a sweat. Running rhino 4900's.

13btoyrota 07.29.2009 09:34 AM

While talking to somone at my local hobby shop i noticed a large 36x60mm motor behind them and it turned out to be a larg ducted fan motor from a plain. It is a himark 36-34-1850kv motor it looked like a good quality motor
and had all the corect size bolt holes, shaft size and is fined heat sink can.

It is rated at 1850kvand dose upto 22v and is rated around 1200wats and in the ductec fan setup will do 2000grams or 2 kg of thrust so i purchased the motor and put it in my buggy and its PURRFECT. With the 13t pinion and 46t spure it has just the right speed and the motor didnt even go above 65c and the esc and lipo's just got warm and i didnt even see the fan run on the MMM.

I stoped running it after 15min and seem it would still go for longer as i normaly only get 10min so the run time is also allot better.
This motor was also only $99 aus dollars and so far seems to be a good one and first run is better than the feigao motor ever was.:yipi:

florianz 07.29.2009 09:44 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by 13btoyrota (Post 308359)
While talking to somone at my local hobby shop i noticed a large 36x60mm motor behind them and it turned out to be a larg ducted fan motor from a plain. It is a himark 36-34-1850kv motor it looked like a good quality motor
and had all the corect size bolt holes, shaft size and is fined heat sink can.

It is rated at 1850kvand dose upto 22v and is rated around 1200wats and in the ductec fan setup will do 2000grams or 2 kg of thrust so i purchased the motor and put it in my buggy and its PURRFECT. With the 13t pinion and 46t spure it has just the right speed and the motor didnt even go above 65c and the esc and lipo's just got warm and i didnt even see the fan run on the MMM.

I stoped running it after 15min and seem it would still go for longer as i normaly only get 10min so the run time is also allot better.
This motor was also only $99 aus dollars and so far seems to be a good one and first run is better than the feigao motor ever was.:yipi:

looks good that motor. is it a 2- or four pole motor? there are some interesting alternatives amongst the plane motors.


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 11:51 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions Inc.