Agreed. Seen plenty of maxxes running L can sized motors, stick with 4 or 5s and you cant go wrong- just gear accordingly (30-40mph region with a stock-ish weight truck).
would an e-maxx 3905 handle an neu 1521 or 1527 motor ?
I doubt the diffs would last. A 1515 size motor can handle just about any emaxx combo, save for some giant tires or ultra speed setup. If you are just bashing a 1515 will be plenty.
A 1527 is a big fraking motor. You might be able to make it work, but it will need a lot of work/mods to be anywhere near somewhat reliable. I imagine you may spend more time repairing the driveline than drving it. Forget about ever having the F wheels on the ground.
A 1521 would probably work, but again would need some work to be reliable, esp if you want to go big power. I can't imagine the little TRX diffs and plastic driveshafts living very long under that much power. I don't know how well the tranny or slipper will fair. The tranny and slipper on my Revo blows up enough w/ the 1515s and 1512s I've had in it.
Really comes down to how much cash you want to spend and how insane you want it to be. Bigger than a 1515 is OTT.
I have been using a 1512/3D 6s lipo combo (1700kv) for over two years now with great success, excellent temps, and perfect power for bashing and racing. Max temps I see in 85F weather is around 125F when racing, and 145F when hard bashing. Although a 1512 motor DOES work for a 1/8 (revo, maxx, maybe truggy), I would recommend a 1515 just for the sake of lower temps (even the temps I get are well within safe limit).
Power levels on my setup have hit 2400watts spikes running 6s G3 lipo and geared for 45mph.
If you are wanting to have a truggy in the future, I would definately get the 1515 motor, just because a truggy does not have the air flow that a monter truck like a maxx or Revo has, so they would run hotter in a truggy, or buggy.
IMO, I would get a 1515 motor, just an overall better bet, you are not getting much of a benefit with 1512, besides lower rotor enertia, a more snappy feel, and a lower motor weight as well, which might be nice in a "light weight" setup.
“The modern astrophysical concept that ascribes the sun’s energy to thermonuclear reactions deep in the solar interior is contradicted by nearly every observable aspect of the sun.” —Ralph E. Juergens