I bought a Neu 1512 2.5 D/F thinking I was going to use 4s for my conversion. Well, things have changed and I have decided I want to use 6s. I would like to trade for a 1512 3 D/F or a 1512 3.5 D/F.
No, I didn't misread. I know it's a bit higher than most people normally run, but it'll work fine. Someone posted efficiency graphs on the Neu motor and they hold pretty good efficiency up to around 57k rpm. As long as the gearing is kept reasonable, amp draws would be about the same as a lower rpm motor geared higher. The amount of work doesn't change, just how you get it...
a bigger pinion will put the motor farther off center making it more equal to the heavier battery weight on the other side.
how old is the motor?
Kind of a weak reason IMO. For a given spur, the difference in motor position between say 18T and 10T pinions is only 4mm, and that's quite a difference in tooth counts.